Confederate memorial inscription in Lawrenceville

Gwinnett County Solicitor General Brian Whiteside filed a complaint against the county in Gwinnett County Superior Court, asking a judge to order the removal of this Confederate memorial from the grounds of the Gwinnett County Historic Courthouse on the Lawrenceville Square.

Evoking memories of violence that broke out in Charlottesville, Va., three years ago over a Confederate monument, Gwinnett County Solicitor General Brian Whiteside filed a complaint in Gwinnett Superior Court this past week to seek the removal of a Confederate monument in Lawrenceville.

Whiteside had previously sent a letter to county commissioners, asking them to remove the monument, which is located on the grounds of the Gwinnett County Historic Courthouse. He pivoted on Tuesday, however, and took his request to a judge instead, seeking a solution similar to one that was used to remove a Confederate monument in Decatur.

The argument outlined in the complaint, officially filed against the county, is that Whiteside sees the monument as a public nuisance because it has been the target of vandals, and he is concerned that it could become the scene of violent clashes between supporters of Confederate monuments and those who oppose them.

In doing so, he recalled a Unite The Right Rally that occurred in Charlottesville in 2017. One woman’s death was tied to the rally after a vehicle was driven into a crowd of counter-protesters.

“The Confederate monument located on the Lawrenceville Square could easily become a rallying and flashpoint for violence similar to the event in August 2017 in Charlottesville, (Va.); thus creating a public safety concern for the city of Lawrenceville and Gwinnett County,” Whiteside wrote in his complaint.

“In recent days, in the midst of historic, nationwide protests of the killings of unarmed black men, the Confederate monument in Lawrenceville has become the focus of justifiable anger and frustration, an impetus for protests and rallies, and most importantly, an urgent, impending threat to public safety.”

Whiteside’s actions are not the only steps being taken to get the Confederate monument removed from the grounds of the historic courthouse, which is a county-owned park and event space. In light of the protests over the killings of George Floyd, Ahmaud Arbery, Breonna Taylor and Rayshard Brooks among others, the monument has been the target of people who see Confederate monuments and statues as symbols of hate.

The monument was erected by the Sons of Confederate Veterans and the United Daughters of the Confederacy in 1993.

In addition to the steps taken by Whiteside, Gwinnett County Board of Commissioners District 1 candidate Kirkland Carden, an African-American, and former 7th Congressional District candidate Nabilah Islam, a first-generation Bangladeshi-American, launched a petition on Change.org last month calling for the removal.

More than 1,900 people had signed the petition, which has a goal of 2,500 signatures, as of Friday afternoon.

The petition, as well as Whiteside’s complaint in Superior Court, point out at least one lynching of an African-American took place on the Lawrenceville Square, about 10 yards away from where the monument stands.

Whiteside said in his complaint that Lawrenceville police were called to the monument on June 8 on a report that it had been vandalized with the damage estimated to be valued at $500. The marker had been spray painted with a stencil “Black Lives Matter” logo.

There were also “signs that had a long message on them, stating remarks about racism and white supremacy,” Whiteside said in the compaint.

“Every time such incidents of graffiti and vandalism occur, city resources are expended,” the solicitor general wrote. “This includes investigating potential criminal damage to the property, coordinating clean-up efforts with the monument and responding to media inquiries.”

Although city police are called to respond to the vandalism, the city has no authority over the monument since it is on county property run by the Gwinnett County Parks and Recreation Division.

State law was changed last year to protect Confederate monuments by increasing penalties for vandalizing them and making it harder to remove them. Local communities have been going through the courts, however, as a workaround to get the monuments removed and sent to museums or put into storage.

That was how the Confederate monument in Decatur was removed last month, after a judge ordered it be taken down.

State Rep. Shelly Hutchinson, D-Snellville, filed legislation this year to have Confederate monuments, as well as statues honoring Confederate soldiers or officials who advocated slavery, banned from public property, but that bill stalled in the Georgia House of Representatives.

Whiteside suggested a judge order the monument on the Lawrenceville Square be moved to the Gwinnett Environmental and Historical Center, which has a museum of some county history.

“The Confederate monument that the community does not want has become a figurative powder keg and thus a public nuisance that must be abated quickly,” the solicitor general wrote in the complaint. “Relocating the monument temporarily will prevent injury and unrest while at the same time protecting and preserving the monument in compliance with — and indeed fulfillment of — Georgia law.”

Support Local Journalism

Now, more than ever, the world needs trustworthy reporting—but good journalism isn’t free. Please support us by subscribing or making a contribution today.

I'm a Crawford Long baby who grew up in Marietta and eventually wandered to the University of Southern Mississippi for college. Earned a BA in journalism (double minor in political science and history). Previously worked in Florida and Clayton County.

(4) comments

Redskin

Big concern is about the monument being vandalized so it is considered a public nuisance. Why not find the criminals that did the BLM spray painting, arrest and prosecute. These criminals are getting away scott free!! If my blue car offends you, walk around it. You don't have to look. The same goes for our monuments!! Learn from them!! All BLM folks need to read up on the teachings of MLK, or do they even know who that is?

Robo40

The Confederate war was not solely about slavery. I get that Confederate statues, most memorizing NOT celebrating, those that died in the conflict. History should not be forgotten. But perhaps the purpose of these monuments is complete and they know longer need to be displayed in town centers and state capitals. But I complete disagree with their destruction. I think it is both a shameful act to destroy these historic works of art. And communities that allow them to be vandalized and destroyed without punishment will regret their inaction. I see a time in the future where anyone decides they don't like a display of something...let's say a tribute to Martin Luther King Jr., and vandalizing it. If you don't follow the law in one circumstance you cannot apply it to any. If the majority of a community feels these historic monuments no longer serve a purpose, they should be allowed to be removed in a respectful way and preserved. Whether that means moving them to a national park or two that is dedicated to the historical artifacts and monuments of the Confederate War. I would suggest Stone Mountain Park or one of the national battlefields. All lives matter, and no specific life matters more than another.

Magic7

I resent Mr. Whiteside stating that the community doesn't want the monument. I am part of the community, and I want it to stay. Do not speak for me or presume that the monument is not wanted. I find it astonishing that these knee-jerk reactions are happening. You can't erase history. Mr. Whiteside you are not the judge and jury. You are a black man trying to flex your muscles. Do your job and prosecute those who have broken the law? If you want to police, then go back to the police department or the sheriff's office. The only reason you are pursuing this is because you are black and are trying to force your black views on others.

MarvinGardens

I am white and I favor the monument's removal. It's not just a black point of view. Most confederate monuments were an attempt to sanitize history, not preserve it. Removing them won't erase history. Can we please stop acting like the Confederacy was some sort of noble cause?

Welcome to the discussion.

Please log in, or sign up for a new, free account to read or post comments.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.